DETROIT – Caught in a terrible 1869 storm and taking on water, the crew of the 144-foot schooner, the Nucleus, did everything they could to save the ship, but couldn’t keep it afloat any longer and realized they had just one option left: abandon ship.

The sailors survived, but the Nucleus sank, slipping into Lake Superior’s icy waters, unseen until now.

“This is a pretty significant shipwreck,” Shipwreck Society Executive Director Bruce Lynn said Wednesday. “Considering its age, the fact that it is a barquentine and we can’t overlook the vessel’s checkered past. The wreck site is littered with shovels too, and a few dinner plates, which speaks to their work and shipboard life.”

What do I do if I find a shipwreck? What to know about ownership laws, artifacts and more  

Watch:Coins found near ‘holy grail of shipwrecks’  

The Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society, which looks for shipwrecks, said it found the wreck in 2021 under 600 feet of water, calling it “one of the oldest ships to go down along Lake Superior’s Shipwreck Coast.” The group positively identified identified it as the Nucleus in 2022.

An anchor from the Nucleus, a ship that sank in Lake Superior, but was found by the the Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society in Paradise.

The Nucleus was found, as other wrecks have, by the shipwreck society using the same sonar as underwater surveyors, archeologists and treasure hunters, and then a remotely operated vehicle to explore it. The ship, society the director of marine operations said, is in “surprisingly good condition.”

The stern, the back, and the port side were intact.

Last year, after searching more than 2,500 miles of the bottom of Lake Superior, the Atlanta – a 172-foot schooner-barge that also sank during a terrible storm – was found, preserved in the lake just as it was when it went down more than 130 years ago.

Even the gold letters of the ship’s nameplate were still visible.